![]() | REVIEW ARTICLE | |||||||
| DOI: 10.1099/vir.0.18942-0 | ||||||||
| Online 28 May 2003 | ||||||||
|
|
Vaccinia virus replication takes place in the cytoplasm of the host cell. The nearly 200 kbp genome owes part of its complexity to encoding most of the proteins involved in genome and mRNA synthesis. The multisubunit vaccinia virus RNA polymerase requires a separate set of virus-encoded proteins for the transcription of the early, intermediate and late classes of genes. Cell fractionation studies have provided evidence for a role for host cell proteins in the initiation and termination of vaccinia virus intermediate and late gene transcription. Vaccinia virus resembles nuclear DNA viruses in the integration of viral and host proteins for viral mRNA synthesis, yet is markedly less reliant on host proteins than its nuclear counterparts.
| INTRODUCTION |
Poxviruses are a family of large DNA genome viruses pathogenic for
many species of mammals, birds and insects. Their genomes are dsDNA
molecules, ranging from 130 kpb (kbp) in parapoxviruses to about
300 kbp in avipoxviruses, with hairpin termini (reviewed by Moss,
2001
).
A feature that distinguishes poxviruses from other classes of DNA
viruses is that the virus remains in the cell cytoplasm for the
duration of the infectious cycle from the time the virus enters the
cell until the progeny viruses exit through the plasma membrane
(Minnigan & Moyer, 1985
). This scenario has fostered the
notion that poxviruses have evolved to a high level of independence
from the host cell, especially for processes involved in DNA
replication and mRNA synthesis that otherwise would be expected to
occur within the nucleus. It is becoming increasingly clear,
however, that poxviruses borrow several host proteins to synthesize
mRNA. Poxviruses distinguish themselves from nuclear DNA viruses in
the relative proportion of transcriptional proteins encoded by the
virus relative to those provided by the host cell.
| TEMPORAL REGULATION OF GENE EXPRESSION |
The majority of information on the regulation of gene expression in
poxviruses has come from studies on the laboratory prototype
poxvirus, vaccinia virus. There is ample reason to regard vaccinia
virus as a model for transcriptional regulation in all poxviruses.
Transcriptional mechanisms appear to be conserved across the entire
family of poxviruses. The RNA polymerase and transcription factor
genes have been found in all poxviruses for which genome sequences
are available, which includes representatives from all poxvirus
genera except entomopoxvirus C. Transcription factors and promoter
function appear to be conserved, since promoters from one type of
poxvirus are functional in a cell infected with a different
poxvirus (Kumar & Boyle, 1990
; Tripathy & Wittek, 1990
).
Like most other classes of virus, poxviruses coordinate the
processes of genome replication and virion assembly through
regulation of the timing of expression of individual genes.
Proteins participating in DNA replication (Jones & Moss,
1984
;
Lee-Chen & Niles, 1988
; Smith et al., 1989a
),
nucleotide biosynthesis (Hruby & Ball, 1982
;
Smith et al., 1989b
) and intermediate gene transcription
(Jones et al., 1987
; Lee-Chen & Niles, 1988
;
Ahn et al., 1990
; Broyles & Pennington, 1990
;
Sanz & Moss, 1999
) are synthesized as early class
genes, and those participating in virion morphogenesis and assembly
tend to be expressed as post-replicative intermediate and late
class gene products (Rosel & Moss, 1985
).
Apparently, it is advantageous to accumulate many copies of the
genome before any virus assembly is to proceed. Proteins involved
in the evasion of host defences tend also to be early class gene
products (Kotwal et al., 1989
;
Moore & Smith, 1992
; Ng et al., 2001
).
The control of gene expression is exerted at the level of
transcription initiation and occurs through a cascade mechanism.
The transcription factors required for intermediate genes are
expressed as early proteins, factors required for late genes are
intermediate gene products and those required for transcription of
early genes are late gene products packaged inside progeny virions
for use in the next cycle of infection. One early vaccinia virus
promoter was shown to reactivate late in the infectious cycle
(Garces et al., 1993
). The significance of reactivation
of early promoters is unclear. It should be noted that a number of
vaccinia virus genes have been described as being continuously
transcribed throughout the infectious cycle. Usually this is
accomplished by a tandem arrangement of early and intermediate or
late promoters preceding the open reading frame (for examples, see
Wittek et al., 1980
; Broyles & Moss, 1986
;
Ahn et al., 1990
; Broyles & Pennington, 1990
).
Virtually all viruses, whether containing DNA or RNA genomes,
couple the switch from early to late gene expression to genome
replication, and vaccinia virus is no exception. Inhibition of DNA
synthesis, either with chemical inhibitors or with conditional
lethal mutations that block DNA replication, results in the
persistence of early gene transcription and the inhibition of
intermediate (Vos & Stunnenberg, 1988
)
and subsequent late gene transcription. With no DNA synthesis, no
transcriptional switch occurs. Curiously, intermediate promoters
when transfected into a virus-infected cell override the block by
inhibition of DNA synthesis and actually continue to be transcribed
at levels higher than when DNA synthesis is allowed to proceed
normally. The continued transcription of transfected intermediate
genes in the absence of DNA synthesis presumably occurs because the
onset of late transcription does not occur and this must somehow
limit intermediate transcription under normal conditions. The
resistance of transfected intermediate promoters to the inhibition
of DNA synthesis has been attributed to a requirement for a
'naked' DNA template for intermediate transcription
(Keck et al., 1990
). This concept posits that vaccinia
virus DNA is relatively free of proteins after the onset of DNA
replication; however, we have little information on the proteins
that associate with viral DNA in the cell cytoplasm.
| VACCINIA VIRUS RNA POLYMERASE |
All three classes of vaccinia virus genes are transcribed by the
virus-encoded RNA polymerase. This enzyme is remarkably complex,
being composed of nine subunits totalling more than 500 kDa in mass
(Table 1) (Moss,
1994
).
The 147 and 136 kDa subunits show a high degree of amino acid
similarity to the two largest subunits of eukaryotic and
prokaryotic cellular RNA polymerases (Broyles & Moss, 1986
;
Patel & Pickup, 1989
). In the bacterial RNA polymerase
and RNA polymerase II from yeast, these two subunits come together
to form a crab claw-shaped structure with a cleft that is the site
of template interaction and the active site for phosphodiester bond
formation (Davis et al., 2002
;
Murakami et al., 2002
). The other subunits interact with
the opposite face of the protein, distant from the catalytic site
of the enzyme and, thus, are proposed to interact with
transcription factors. Other than a modest similarity between the
smallest vaccinia virus RNA polymerase subunit (7 kDa) and the
smallest subunit of yeast RNA polymerase II (RBP10) (Amegadzie
et al., 1992a
), the smaller subunits of vaccinia
virus RNA polymerase have no significant resemblance to the smaller
subunits of cellular RNA polymerases, possibly owing to the lack of
sequence similarity to any vaccinia virus transcription factors to
known cellular transcription factors.
Table 1. Proteins participating in vaccinia virus transcription
|
Protein
|
Encoding gene |
Reference |
|
RNA polymerases |
||
|
147 kDa |
J6R |
|
|
133 kDa |
A24R |
|
|
94 kDa |
H4R |
|
|
35 kDa |
A29L |
|
|
30 kDa |
E4L |
|
|
22 kDa |
J4R |
|
|
19 kDa |
A5R |
|
|
18 kDa |
D7R |
|
|
7 kDa |
G5.5R |
|
|
Early transcription factors |
||
|
82 kDa |
A7L |
|
|
70 kDa |
D6R |
|
|
Early termination factors |
||
|
VTF (capping enzyme) |
||
|
97 kDa |
D1R |
|
|
33 kDa |
D12L |
|
|
Nucleoside phosphohydrolase I |
||
|
72 kDa |
D11L |
|
|
Intermediate transcription factors |
||
|
Capping enzyme |
D1R, D12L |
|
|
VITF-1 (RNA polymerase subunit) |
E4L |
|
|
VITF-2 |
Host |
|
|
VITF-3 44 kDa |
A23R |
|
|
VITF-3 33 kDa |
A8R |
|
|
YY1 |
Host |
|
|
Late transcription factors |
||
|
VLTF-1 30 kDa |
G8R |
|
|
VLTF-2 17 kDa |
A1L |
|
|
VLTF-3 26 kDa |
A2L |
|
|
VLTF-X |
A2/B1, RBM3 (Host) |
|
|
Intermediate/late termination factors |
||
|
Termination/mRNA release |
A18R |
|
|
Termination/mRNA release |
Host |
|
|
Elongation factor |
G2R |
|
|
Elongation factor J3R |
J3R |
|
| EARLY GENE TRANSCRIPTION |
Vaccinia virus early class mRNA appears within minutes after virus
entry into the cell. The virion core particle apparently retains
much of its structural integrity after cell entry. Viral mRNA is
synthesized within the confines of the core particle and is
extruded through pores in its surface (Kates & McAuslan,
1967
;
Munyon et al., 1967
). This is possible because all the
enzymes and other proteins required to synthesize mature mRNA are
packaged within the virion core along with the DNA genome. These
proteins include RNA modification enzymes such as the mRNA capping
enzyme, poly(A) polymerase and a 2´-O-methyltransferase
in addition to the RNA synthesis machinery.
Approximately half of the vaccinia virus genes belong to the early
class (Oda & Joklik, 1967
). A single early promoter, that of
the 7.5K gene, has been characterized in detail (Davison &
Moss, 1989b
). Early promoters can be studied
in vivo only in the context of being resident in the viral
genome. Transfected early promoter/reporter gene constructs are not
functional (unpublished observations), presumably because they
cannot access the interior of the core particle where the salient
proteins reside. Analysis of the 7.5K promoter identified a single
essential element upstream of the transcription start site spanning
nt 12 to 29. Inspection of a number of
early promoters reveals that each has a nearly universal G residue
at 21 or 22 that is flanked by a
sequence that is variable but highly AT rich (Fig. 1) (Davison & Moss, 1989b
).
Fig. 1. Comparison of sequence elements in vaccinia virus early,
intermediate and late promoters. Numbers following letters indicate
the number of continuously repeating residues. 'N'
indicates any of the four nucleotides. Arrows indicate
transcriptional start sites, referred to as nt +1 in the text. The
precise start site in intermediate and late promoters cannot be
determined because of RNA polymerase slippage in the oligo(A)
tract.
The initiation of early mRNA synthesis is accomplished by a
remarkably simple set of proteins. Highly efficient transcription
reactions can be reconstituted in vitro on the early gene
template using only the viral RNA polymerase and a single
transcription factor, the vaccinia virus early transcription factor
(ETF) (Broyles et al., 1988
). ETF is a heterodimer of the viral
D6R and A7L gene products (Broyles & Fesler, 1990
;
Gershon & Moss, 1990
) and is the only known
poxvirus-encoded promoter-binding protein. It interacts with two
regions of early promoters: nt 12 to
29, relative to the transcription start site, and nt
+7 to +10, downstream of the transcription start site (Broyles
et al., 1991
; Cassetti & Moss, 1996
).
Thus, the factor contacts the promoter on both sides flanking the
transcription start site, apparently without blocking the template
at the site of initiation. The 12 to 29
contacts correspond to the early promoter element identified by
Davison & Moss (1989b
), thus accounting for the promoter
sequence requirements. Methylation interference experiments
indicate that ETF contacts the invariant G residue within this
sequence as well as A residues in the minor groove of the DNA helix
(Broyles et al., 1991
; unpublished results).
Minor groove contacts explain the variation in sequence tolerated
by ETF because the chemical groups presented in the minor groove of
an AT base pair are very similar to that of a
TA base pair. The downstream contacts made by ETF are
not sequence specific, appearing to be 'mooring'
contacts that stabilize the proteinDNA complex. The
ETFpromoter complex recruits the RNA polymerase to the
site of initiation (Li & Broyles, 1993
)
and RNA synthesis presumably resumes thereafter.
The initiation of early mRNA synthesis requires ATP as an energy
source that is distinct from the adenosine nucleotide incorporated
into RNA. ATP analogues with a non-hydrolysable
bond
can be incorporated into RNA chains by the viral RNA polymerase on
artificial single-stranded templates, yet do not support
transcription from vaccinia virus early promoters (Gershowitz et
al., 1978
). An explanation for the ATP
requirement emerged with the discovery of an ATPase activity
associated with ETF (Broyles & Moss, 1988
).
The ATPase activity is DNA dependent, with little regard for the
form or sequence of DNA. Mutations in the conserved ATPase motifs,
such as the P loop and DEAH box in ETF, inactivate its
transcription factor activity in vitro (Li & Broyles,
1995
).
ATP hydrolysis induces the accelerated dissociation of the
ETFpromoter complex (Broyles, 1991
). Taken together,
these results suggest a model in which ETF recruits the RNA
polymerase to the transcriptional start site but simultaneously
presents a steric hindrance to the RNA polymerase because of
ETF's DNA contacts on the downstream side of the RNA
polymerase (Fig. 2).
The release of ETF concurrent with ATP hydrolysis removes the
impediment and RNA polymerase could then begin to traverse the
template for RNA polymerization.
Fig. 2. A
model for vaccinia virus early transcription. (A) ETF targets the
upstream element of the early promoter. Note that ETF interacts
with nucleotides 5´and 3´ of the transcriptional
initiation site. (B) ETF recruits the RNA polymerase (POL) to the
transcriptional initiation site. (C) ATP hydrolysis by ETF releases
it from the complex to allow the RNA polymerase to escape from the
initiation site.
Another polypeptide specific for early gene transcription is the 95
kDa subunit of the RNA polymerase that is the H4L gene product.
About half of the virion-derived RNA polymerase contains this
subunit. Heparinagarose chromatography is capable of
separating RNA polymerase into a population containing, and one
deficient in, the H4L subunit (Ahn et al., 1994
). Only the
fraction containing the H4L subunit supports transcription on early
promoter templates in vitro (Ahn et al., 1994
). In
addition, antibodies directed against the H4L polypeptide inhibit
early gene transcription (Deng & Shuman, 1994
).
Taken together, these results imply that H4L may have a role in
docking RNA polymerase to the ETFDNA complex, although
this has not been demonstrated directly. Interestingly, H4L has
also been shown to have a role in docking several proteins in the
transcription elongation complex and is essential for termination
of early gene transcription (see below). RNA polymerase deficient
for this polypeptide is quite competent to catalyse transcription
on late promoter templates (Wright & Coroneos, 1995
).
Thus, H4L appears to have multiple specific roles in early gene
transcription.
Several lines of evidence indicate that the early transcription
machinery, complete with RNA modification enzymes, may assemble on
early promoters during morphogenesis and assembly into progeny
virions. Virion extracts yield a RNA polymerase
'holoenzyme' capable of transcription of early gene
templates in vitro (Broyles & Moss, 1987
).
This complex contained ETF, capping enzyme, poly(A) polymerase and
the transcription termination factor NPH I (nucleoside
phosphohydrolase I). Inhibition of synthesis of the RNA polymerase
H4L subunit, thought to dock with ETF, resulted in progeny virions
that had normal ETF content but were deficient in RNA polymerase,
poly(A) polymerase and capping enzyme (Zhang et al.,
1993
). Similarly, viruses with ETF having
impaired promoter-binding activity packaged reduced levels of ETF,
RNA polymerase, capping enzyme, poly(A) polymerase and NPH I within
their virion particles (Li et al., 1994
).
Finally, inhibition of expression of either subunit of ETF caused
severe defects in morphogenesis (Hu et al., 1996
,
1998
).
The simplest interpretation of these findings is that the complete
early transcription complex is anchored at early promoters during
virion assembly through ETF and its complex with the RNA polymerase,
and assembly of the transcription complex is an early event in
virion morphogenesis. A study by Cassetti et al. (1998
)
seems to contradict the DNA-mediated assembly of vaccinia virus
transcription factors. A virus in which the gene A32L product was
repressed failed to package significant amounts of DNA (Cassetti
et al., 1998
). The A32L-deficient virus was,
nonetheless, capable of packaging proteins participating in early
gene transcription, including ETF. Therefore, factors other than
assembly on transcriptional promoters may contribute to the
assembly of transcriptional proteins into the virion core.
| INTERMEDIATE GENE TRANSCRIPTION |
Until recently, vaccinia virus intermediate genes were believed to
be few in number. They were uncovered initially by the
identification of promoters that required the onset of DNA
synthesis but lacked the TAAATG motif at the start site for
transcription previously regarded as diagnostic for late promoters
(Vos & Stunnenberg, 1988
). Intermediate promoters are more
prevalent in the vaccinia virus genome than previously appreciated,
because many have the TAAATG motif at the start of their open
reading frames, which was previously attributed to late gene
promoters (X. Liu and S. S. Broyles, unpublished results). The RNA
polymerase initiates on this motif within the A triplet (actually
on the T triplet on the template strand) and slips repeatedly while
attempting to initiate transcription (Bertholet et al.,
1987
;
Schwer et al., 1987
). The result is mRNA with a 5´
end bearing a heterogeneous oligo(A) tail, averaging about 30 nt in
length that is not template encoded. The significance of the
5´ oligo(A) tail for mRNA function is not known.
Intermediate promoters are bipartite, having an initiator element
at the transcriptional start site and an AT-rich
upstream element (Fig. 1) (Baldick
et al., 1992
). The initiator element minimally
has the sequence TAAAT/A at nt 1 to +4 relative to
the first A in the motif (Baldick et al., 1992
).
Many, but not all, intermediate promoters have the dinucleotide GG
immediately 3´ of the TAAAT motif (X. Liu and S. S. Broyles,
unpublished results), constituting a binding site for the nuclear
transcription factor YinYang1 (YY1) in the form of the sequence
TAAATGG. YY1 binds this sequence in the initiator element of the
intermediate I1L promoter (Broyles et al., 1999
).
The I1L promoter was initially described as a late class promoter
(Vos & Stunnenberg, 1988
) but is now know to be an
intermediate class promoter (X. Liu and S. S. Broyles, unpublished
results). Replacement of the GG dinucleotide with C residues
impaired binding to YY1 in vitro and reduced the I1L
promoter's activity by about 90 % in vivo. The
co-crystal structure of the DNA-binding domain of YY1 and the
sequence AAAATGG showed that the TTT motif, on which the vaccinia
virus RNA polymerase must initiate transcription, faces away from
the YY1 interface (Houbaviy et al., 1996
)
and is thus available for engagement. YY1 accumulates in the
cytoplasm of vaccinia virus-infected cells, consistent with a role
in transcription of the viral genome (Broyles et al.,
1999
).
Several virus-encoded proteins are required for intermediate gene
transcription. De novo synthesis of viral RNA polymerase is
probably required for vaccinia virus intermediate gene
transcription. Temperature-sensitive RNA polymerase mutants are
defective for late transcription, suggesting that new RNA
polymerase is required for late transcription (Hooda-Dhingra et
al., 1989
). This observation was reported
prior to the discovery of intermediate genes. All RNA polymerase
subunit genes whose transcripts have been characterized have early
promoters. Therefore, intermediate transcription is likely to
require new RNA polymerase also. Either the RNA polymerase brought
into the cell by the infecting virion is rendered inactive upon
uncoating of the genome and/or is incapable of supporting the
burden of RNA synthesis activity necessary for intermediate and
late transcription. In addition, the form of RNA polymerase that is
most efficient in late gene transcription in vitro is the
form that lacks the H4L polypeptide (Wright & Coroneos,
1995
). The H4L gene is transcribed as a
late class gene (Rosel et al., 1986
)
(although this has not been verified since the discovery of
intermediate genes) and, therefore, should not be present during
intermediate gene transcription. This means that any
transcriptional process that is H4L-dependent is not likely to be
functional for intermediate or late gene transcription.
At least four other proteins have been reported from two
laboratories to be required for transcription from the I3L
intermediate promoter in vitro. Vos and co-workers described
two factors, ITF-A and ITF-B, that had intermediate transcription
factor activity (Vos et al., 1991b
).
ITF-B is the viral capping enzyme and a fraction containing ITF-A
was shown to have promoter DNA-melting activity (Vos et al.,
1991a
, b
). Moss and co-workers have
identified the intermediate factors VITF-1, VITF-2 (Rosales et
al., 1994a
) and VITF-3 (Sanz & Moss,
1998
)
and confirmed a requirement for the viral capping enzyme in
intermediate transcription (Harris et al., 1993
).
VITF-1 is the 30 kDa subunit of the viral RNA polymerase (Rosales
et al., 1994a
). VITF-3 is a heterodimer of the
viral A8L and A23R gene products (Sanz & Moss, 1999
).
VITF-2 was identified in nuclear extracts from uninfected HeLa
cells (Rosales et al., 1994b
),
documenting the first known vaccinia virus transcription factor
that is not virus encoded. The identity of the nuclear protein is
not known nor is a molecular function for any VITF proteins or
capping enzyme. The latter protein likely has a tethering role,
linking one of the other factors to the RNA polymerase. The capping
enzyme has been reported to be complexed with RNA polymerase in
solution (Broyles & Moss, 1987
). Whether any of these proteins
targets either of the two elements in intermediate promoters is not
known.
Protein phosphorylation has been implicated in intermediate
transcription through a characterization of vaccinia virus mutants
defective for the B1R protein kinase (Kovacs et al.,
2001
).
B1R is a serine/threonine protein kinase (Traktman et al.,
1989
;
Banham & Smith, 1992
; Lin et al., 1992
)
previously characterized as being required for DNA replication
(Condit & Motyczka, 1981
; Condit et al., 1983
).
The recent study found that B1R mutants are also defective for
intermediate gene transcription but not late gene transcription.
These findings suggest that one or more proteins functioning in
intermediate transcription may require phosphorylation for
function, but the substrate for the kinase that functions in
intermediate transcription has not been reported.
| LATE TRANSCRIPTION |
Vaccinia virus late promoters also have a bipartite structure with
an initiator-like element at the start site for transcription and
an AT-rich upstream element (Fig. 1) (Davison & Moss, 1989a
).
The initiator element has the nearly invariant sequence TAAAT.
Nucleotides downstream of this sequence do not have a role in
transcription. The upstream element is closer to the initiator than
the intermediate promoters are, being located at about nt
16 to 11 (X. Liu and S. S. Broyles,
unpublished results). Like the upstream element of intermediate
promoters, the late element seems to tolerate considerable
variation in sequence.
As described above, late transcription requires newly synthesized
RNA polymerase (Hooda-Dhingra et al., 1989
).
Three other virus-encoded transcription factors were identified by
Moss and colleagues by asking which viral genes must be
co-transfected with a reporter gene driven by a vaccinia virus late
promoter under conditions where DNA synthesis was inhibited (Keck
et al., 1990
). G8R, A1L and A2L constituted the
minimal set of genes required for late promoter activity. All three
are intermediate class genes. No function has been ascribed to any
of the three. A yeast two-hybrid screen suggested that the G8R and
A1L proteins are interaction partners (McCraith et al.,
2000
).
A fourth factor, the product of the H5L gene, was identified
through cell fractionation studies as having transcription
stimulatory activity (Kovacs et al., 1994
;
Kovacs & Moss, 1996
). The H5L gene belongs to the early
class of vaccinia virus genes and, hence, would have escaped
attention in transfection studies. The H5L protein is a substrate
for the B1R protein kinase (Beaud et al., 1995
)
and an interaction between H5L and B1R was detected in a yeast
two-hybrid screen (McCraith et al., 2000
),
suggesting that protein phosphorylation may have a role in
regulating the function of this transcription factor. An effect of
phosphorylation on the protein function of H5R has not been
reported, nor has its phosphorylation status in vivo.
A fifth late transcription factor has been identified by Wright and
colleagues, also through cell fractionation (Wright et al.,
1998
). This factor, called VLTF-X, was
initially reported as being virus-induced (Wright & Coroneos,
1993
) but, subsequently, was identified
in cytoplasmic and nuclear extracts from uninfected HeLa cells
(Gunasinghe et al., 1998
) and is, therefore, a host protein
implicated in vaccinia virus late transcription. Interestingly,
this factor co-purified with a DNA-binding activity that
demonstrated some specificity for oligo(T)-tract sequences. This is
of interest because it has been reported that oligo(T) tracts are
functional as an upstream element in a late vaccinia virus promoter
(Davison & Moss, 1989a
). Thus, it is possible that VLTF-X
is responsible for targeting late vaccinia virus promoters as sites
of initiation. The transcriptional stimulation activity associated
with VLTF-X can be fulfilled by either heterogeneous nuclear
riboproteins A2/B1 or RBM3 (Wright et al., 2001
).
The failure to identify any vaccinia virus-encoded factors with
promoter-binding activity prompts speculation that host factors may
target the viral promoters, forming a nucleation site for
virus-encoded factors that eventually recruit the RNA polymerase to
the site of initiation (Fig.
3).
Fig. 3. A
hypothetical model to explain the requirement for a host
DNA-binding protein in addition to the virus-encoded factors A1, A2
and G8 in late gene transcription. The host nuclear factor (NF)
targets its recognition motif in the upstream element of the
promoter (UE). The virus-encoded factors facilitate the assembly of
the RNA polymerase (POL) at the transcription initiation site
(TAAAT).
| ELONGATION OF TRANSCRIPTION |
Virtually all DNA-dependent RNA polymerases pause during the
elongation phase of transcription (Uptain et al., 1997
;
Conaway & Conaway, 1999
; Gnatt, 2002
).
The rate at which the enzyme traverses the DNA template is not
constant, but rather it can slow dramatically at discrete sequences
in the DNA. The pauses are readily detected as less-than
full-length transcripts that persist during the course of an in
vitro transcription experiment. Vaccinia virus RNA polymerase
has been shown to pause in vitro, especially under
conditions of limiting nucleotide concentration (Deng & Shuman,
1997
).
The pauses were reduced by the presence of the virus-encoded NPH I
and ATP (Deng & Shuman, 1998
). NPH I is a ssDNA-dependent ATPase
with nucleic acid helicase motifs in its amino acid sequence. It
has been proposed that NPH I weakens the interaction between the
RNA polymerase and template DNA to allow movement of the RNA
polymerase. It is noted that NPH I has not been demonstrated to
have nucleic acid helicase activity.
Two proteins have been implicated in the elongation of transcription on vaccinia virus intermediate and late genes. The G2R and J3R proteins have been suggested to enhance rates of transcription elongation in a manner that likely impacts the ability of the RNA polymerase to terminate and release post-replicative transcripts (see below).
| EARLY GENE TRANSCRIPTION TERMINATION |
Transcription of vaccinia virus early genes terminates just
downstream of open reading frames in response to the sequence
TTTTTNT (where N is any nucleotide) on the non-template strand of
the DNA (Yuen & Moss, 1987
). Termination occurs heterogeneously
about 3050 nt downstream of the signal. At least two
trans-acting factors are required to induce termination and
transcript release by the RNA polymerase. The termination signal is
actually sensed in the form of the sequence UUUUUNU in the nascent
RNA, a conclusion derived from the observation that bromo-UTP
specifically inhibits the termination of transcription in
vitro (Shuman & Moss, 1988
). Presumably the RNA polymerase
carries the capping enzyme along as it transverses the template as
an elongation complex. As the termination signal in the RNA is
extruded from the elongating RNA polymerase, the capping enzyme, by
an as yet undefined mechanism, induces the RNA polymerase to cease
transcription and release the template. The termination process has
been proposed to be the result of a kinetic balance between
transcription elongation rates and signalling through the capping
enzyme (Deng & Shuman, 1997
). Reaction conditions that slow the
rate of elongation by the RNA polymerase slow the rate of
signalling, thereby shifting termination sites farther downstream.
The second factor, NPH I, was identified following the
demonstration of an ATP requirement for the termination process
(Deng & Shuman, 1998
). NPH I is required for termination
of transcription and transcript release in vitro and for
termination of transcription using extracts from cells infected
with a NPH I mutant virus (Christen et al., 1998
).
As described above, NPH I is a ssDNA-dependent ATPase with nucleic
acid helicase motifs in its amino acid sequence. Five of the six
helicase motifs in NPH I are essential for termination factor
activity (Christen et al., 1998
).
It seems likely that NPH I is the motor that drives dissociation of
the transcription elongation complex in response to the signal in
RNA. A model for termination of early transcription has been
proposed in which RNA polymerase carries capping enzyme and NPH I
as an elongation complex (Deng & Shuman, 1998
).
As the termination signal in the mRNA is extruded from the RNA
polymerase, it contacts the capping enzyme, signalling NPH I to
drive release of the transcript through hydrolysis of ATP (Fig. 4). Contact between
NPH I and the RNA polymerase is supported by evidence for a
requirement for the H4L subunit of the RNA polymerase in
termination of transcription (Mohamed & Niles, 2001
)
and demonstration of direct interaction between NPH I and the H4L
polypeptide (Mohamed & Niles, 2000
).
Thus, the H4L polypeptide seems to be the key specificity factor
for virtually all aspects of early gene transcription. It is
required for initiation, elongation and termination of early
transcripts. Therefore, the RNA polymerase molecules that lack H4L
would not be expected to perform any of these processes.
Fig. 4. Model
to explain early gene transcriptional termination and transcript
release. The transcription elongation complex, consisting of RNA
polymerase (POL), capping enzyme (CE) and NPH I (N), drives the
movement of the DNA transcription 'bubble' until the
capping enzyme receives the UUUUUNU signal in the extruding RNA.
The complex pauses and the ssDNA in the non-template strand of the
bubble activates the ATPase of NPH I. ATP hydrolysis disrupts the
complex to release the RNA. The dissociation of the complex is
hypothetical. The interaction between CE and the termination signal
in RNA has not been documented directly. Adapted from Deng &
Shuman (1998
).
| TERMINATION OF INTERMEDIATE AND LATE TRANSCRIPTION |
Vaccinia virus RNA polymerase appears not to respond to specific
termination signals in intermediate and late genes. Northern
blotting of these two classes of RNA revealed that their 3´
termini are extremely heterogeneous (for example, see Xiang et al., 2000
, b
). While the location of termination
may not be specified, there is, nevertheless, a growing body of
evidence that there is an active mechanism to induce termination of
transcription on intermediate and late genes (reviewed by Condit
& Niles, 2002
). Genetic studies provided the first
clues to the concept of active termination of intermediate and late
transcription and the proteins participating in the process.
Mutants with lesions in the A18R gene form intermediate transcripts
that are significantly longer than their counterparts from
wild-type virus (Xiang et al., 1998
).
The A18R polypeptide has classical DNA-dependent nucleic acid
helicase motifs and DNA helicase activity specific for DNA:DNA
hybrids less than 20 nt in length (Simpson & Condit, 1995
).
Extracts from infected cells depleted of A18R by growth of the
mutant under non-permissive conditions did not support transcript
release in an in vitro assay (Lackner & Condit,
2000
).
Interestingly, purified A18R was incapable of supporting transcript
release unless extract from uninfected cells was also provided. The
latter result implies a host protein of unknown identity in the
termination process.
A role for the vaccinia virus G2R protein in transcription
termination was initially revealed by the mapping of mutations
conferring dependence on the anti-poxvirus drug isatin
b-thiosemicarbazone (IBT) (Meis & Condit, 1991
).
G2R mutants display a phenotype in which intermediate and late
transcripts are shorter than normal (Black & Condit, 1996
),
just the opposite of that of A18R mutants. The reduced transcript
lengths implied that the G2R protein may play a role in promoting
transcription elongation by the RNA polymerase. An
interrelationship between G2R and A18R was inferred by
demonstrating that G2R mutants could act as extragenic suppressors
of the A18R mutants (Condit et al., 1996
).
An interaction between G2R with the late factor H5R was also
detected in a yeast two-hybrid screen (McCraith et al.,
2000
).
A third protein, the product of the J3R gene, has been implicated
in intermediate and late transcription termination. Additional
IBT-dependent mutants and extragenic suppressors of A18R mutations
indicated that J3R mutants are identical in phenotype to those in
G2R (Latner et al., 2000
; Xiang et al., 2000
).
Post-replicative transcripts from J3R mutants are truncated at
their 3´ ends, supporting the conclusion the J3R protein is
also a positive elongation factor. A role for J3R in transcription
elongation is somewhat surprising because this polypeptide is the
viral mRNA 2´-O-methyltransferase (Schnierle et
al., 1992
) and the stimulatory subunit of the
mRNA poly(A) polymerase (Gershon et al., 1991
).
Mutational analysis showed the mRNA methyltransferase and poly(A)
polymerase stimulatory activities to be distinct from the
elongation factors' properties (Xiang et al., 2000
;
Latner et al., 2002
). An interaction between the J3R
protein and the late transcription stimulatory factor H5R has been
documented in two independent studies (Black et al.,
1998
;
McCraith et al., 2000
); however, the significance of this
complex is not yet apparent. Thus, the termination of
post-replicative transcripts appears to result from a dynamic
balance between maintaining a transcription elongation complex and
promotion of transcript release.
| 3´-END PROCESSING |
The cowpox virus A type inclusion body protein (ati) transcript is
a late class mRNA and has the unusual property of terminating at a
precise location after the open reading frame (Antczak et
al., 1992
). The coding sequence terminates at
a specific nucleotide by a site-specific riboendonucleolytic
cleavage and the 3´end is polyadenylated. The sequence
immediately surrounding the cleavage site and another block of
sequence 10 nt downstream are essential for the cleavage reaction
(Howard et al., 1999
). The same 3´ end is found on
the transcript from the equivalent gene in vaccinia virus
(Amegadzie et al., 1992b
), indicating that the gene structure
is conserved in more than one poxvirus. It is not clear whether
3´-end processing is common in vaccinia virus. Because the
first example of 3´-end processing was found in the highly
abundant ati transcript, it is tempting to speculate that the
processing enhances the expression of highly active genes.
| CONCLUSION |
The emerging picture of vaccinia virus transcription is one in which the majority of proteins required to synthesize a functional mRNA are virus encoded. The early transcription system appears to be performed exclusively by viral proteins and no evidence has been obtained for host functions required for the initiation or termination of early transcripts. The situation is quite different for intermediate and late transcription; key functions for both initiation and termination of intermediate and late transcription appear to be borrowed from the host cell. Why should the intermediate and late systems differ fundamentally from early transcription? Two reasons seem likely: location and timing. The early transcription system is restricted to the confines of the virion core. While the internal structure of the core is a complete enigma, it is likely to be highly ordered. When the core is disassembled, early transcription ceases. Intermediate and late transcription occurs in the cytoplasm in a much more open environment. The timing of transcription may also be a reason for utilizing host proteins. Intermediate and late transcription do not begin until after DNA replication begins. It is possible that host proteins are not recruited to virus replication complexes until sufficient amounts of DNA accumulate in the cytoplasm.
| REFERENCES |
Abu-Daya, A., Brown, P. M. & Fox, K. R. (1995). DNA sequence preferences of several AT-selective minor groove binding ligands. Nucleic Acids Res 23, 33853392.
Broyles, S. S. (1993). Vaccinia virus encodes a functional dUTPase. Virology 195, 863865.
© 2003 SGM
This article is now available in the September 2003 print issue of JGV (vol. 84, 22932303). The complete issue of the journal may be seen in electronic form on JGV Online.